|
|
<<
previous
<<
4 by 3; Local retailer
head-2-head
>>
next >>
Presenter:
|
Richard Whinney (for Laura Kent)
|
| Wines |
Region
/ Country |
Source |
Cost |
Comments |
1. Dorsheimer
Pittermannchen, Michael Schafer 1991 QbA
|
Nahe, Germany
|
Majestic
|
£6.49
|
9.5%. Full
bodied. Mature. Typical oily nose/taste. Classic
Riesling. Incredible for age. Hint of sweetness.
|
2. Eitelsbacher
Karthauserhofberg 2006 Spätlese
|
Mosel, Germany
|
Richard Granger
|
£21.60
|
9.5%. Full
bodied. More primary fruit. Complex. Hint of noble
rot. Exotic fruits.
|
3. Reichsrat von
Buhl 2010 Trocken
|
Pfalz, Germany
|
Carruthers &
Kent
|
£12.49
|
12%. Acid.
Austere. Thin. More like a Chenin. White peach nose. |
4. Moncellier
2010 Sauvignon Blanc
|
Marlborough, New
Zealand
|
Richard Granger
|
£10.98
|
14%. Typical NZ
nose, grassy NZ style, austere lemony sweetness,
metallic finish. What gave NZ a bad name.
|
5. Sherwood
Estate 2008 Clearwater Sauvignon Blanc
|
Waipara Valley,
New Zealand
|
Carruthers &
Kent
|
£13.49
|
13%. Toasted
barrels, oaked sulphur, yeast contact, not enough
acid, complex wine, not attractive to drink.
|
6.
Astolabe 2010 Discovery Sauvignon Blanc
|
Marlborough, New
Zealand
|
Majestic
|
£19.99
|
13%. Sulphur.
Sauv. Blanc on steroids, mango juice, bizzare!,
blackcurrant leaves.
|
7. Selvapiana
Chianti Riserva Rufina 2004
|
Tuscany, Italy
|
Carruthers &
Kent
|
£24.99
|
14%. Good
tannins, drying out, fruity hint of vanilla.
|
8. Nipozzano
Chianti Riserva Rufina 2007
|
Tuscany, Italy
|
Majestic
|
£17.99
|
13.5%. Good
tannins, flat middle, salty nose, tar & spices.
|
9. Cantina del
Montalcino, Poggio del Sasso IGT 2009
|
Tuscany, Italy
|
Richard Granger
|
£8.82
|
13%. Pedestrian,
a nice wine, cherry, big tannins, rustic.
|
10. Vinalba Gran
Reserva 2008
|
Mendoza,
Argentina
|
Majestic
|
£13.99
|
14.5%. Old
blackberry nose, caramel, intrinsic Malbec
sweetness, quite sweet blackcurrant, liquorice.
|
| 11.Pulenta Est.
2008 |
Mendoza,
Argentina
|
Richard Granger
|
£13.99
|
14.5%. Meaty
wood (too much?), blackcurrant, liquorice, rich,
mouth filling.
|
| 12. Colome
Estate 2009 |
Salta, Argentina |
Carruthers &
Kent |
£15.99 |
14.5%. Sulphur
nose, meaty, blackcurrant, liquorice, acidic, stalky.
|
Reviewed on the North East Wino
Blog posting "4
by 3...a NEWTS Tasting"
|
|