Presenter: Karl
Laczko
|
January 2015 minutes:
|
| Wines |
Region |
Country |
Source |
Cost |
Comments |
Type |
1.
Wente
Vineyards 2012
Morning Fog Chardonnay, Livermore Valley
|
California |
USA |
Richard Granger
|
£12
|
13.5% “Peachy
nose”, “nice acid balance”, “sugary sweet
(approach)”, “a little short”, “a touch cloying”.
|
|
2. Kirkland
Signature 2012
Russian River Pinot Noir, Sonoma
|
California |
USA |
Costco
|
£12.90
|
14.2%
Typical Pinot colour and aroma and sweet, if
somewhat simple, fruit: “lacks structure”, “Soft,
jammy sweet”, “promised well”, “Doesn’t stand deep
analysis...but not bad”
|
|
3. Kirkland
Signature 2009 Rutherford Meritage, Napa
|
California |
USA |
Costco
|
£14.38
|
13.9%
Too sweet”, “initial nose medicinal”, “dry
tannins”, it was a pleasant drinker with dusty
tannins, it may improve a little with age.
|
|
4. Kirkland
Signature Series 2012
Oakville Merlot, Napa
|
California |
USA |
Costco
|
£14.38
|
14.5% A good
wine with firm tannins with good fruit. Cool and
soft but with structure, a little light on the
finish. Chocolate and cherries.
|
|
5. Kirkland
Signature 2012
Stags Leap District Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa
|
California |
USA |
Costco
|
£19.20
|
14.6% A perfumed
nose with some rose petal and delicate flavours, a
more “grown up” elegance. Ripe, young fruit finished
with a little chocolate.
|
|
6. Kirkland
Signature 2010
Mountain Cuvée Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa
|
California |
USA |
Costco
|
£16.43
|
14.9% A green
capsicum component, cool fruit and less sweet, more
vegetal aspects.
|
|
7. Kirkland
Signature Series 2010
Oakville Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa
|
California |
USA |
Costco
|
£17.98
|
14.9% A deep,
dark fruited nose with a cool, menthol aspect. While
smooth it had layers and a strong mid-palate.
|
|
8.
Château
Montelena 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa
|
California |
USA |
Costco
|
£29.94
|
13.9% A full
wine, though a little softer and lighter than
expected, the tannins seem lacking although they
built up on subsequent tastes.
|
|
9.
Quady Winery,
Elysium 2011 California Black Muscat, Madera
|
California |
USA |
Costco
|
£7.90 half
bottle
|
15% “Raspberry
syrup”, “inoffensive”, “lacks weight”. Too sweet and
simple for most.
|
|
|
21/01/2015 |
Raffle wine: La Finca 2012 Clos d'Angel Cabernet
Sauvignon
Won by: Karl Laczko |